The Sweetest Year: 3 cakes. 3 different occasions. Coming November 27.

Handcrafted Gourmet Cookies by the Dozen

Some moments deserve more than an ordinary cookie. At Make It Amazing, our gourmet cookies are handcrafted with thoughtfully developed flavors and a touch of indulgence. From timeless classics to specialty favorites, every cookie is made to turn everyday moments into something amazing. Whether you’re celebrating, gifting, sharing, or treating yourself, there’s something sweet waiting for you.

Shop Cookies by the Dozen

Explore All 20 Flavors

Explore All 20 Flavors

The Complete 20-Flavor Menu

Four collections, five flavors each. Seasonal availability may change, and all orders are subject to availability.

Signature Classics

  • Brown Butter Chocolate Chip – Nutty brown butter dough, semisweet chocolate chips and a touch of flaky sea salt.
  • Classic Sugar Cookie – Buttery vanilla sweetness with delicate golden edges.
  • Cinnamon Sugar Snickerdoodle – Tender cookies coated in warm cinnamon sugar.
  • White Chocolate Macadamia – Creamy white chocolate and crunchy macadamia nuts.
  • Oatmeal Raisin – Old-fashioned oats, warm cinnamon and sweet raisins.

Chocolate Lovers

  • Double Chocolate Fudge – Rich cocoa cookie packed with chocolate chips.
  • Cookies & Cream – Vanilla cookie loaded with chocolate sandwich cookies and white chocolate.
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Bliss – Peanut butter and delicious chocolate chips.
  • Mocha Espresso Chip – Chocolate and espresso in one indulgent cookie.
  • Red Velvet White Chocolate – Velvety cocoa flavor with creamy white chocolate.

Gourmet Favorites

  • Biscoff Cookie Butter – Spiced cookie butter and caramelized Biscoff crunch.
  • Salted Caramel Pretzel – Sweet caramel, crunchy pretzels and sea salt.
  • Strawberry Crunch – Strawberry sweetness, white chocolate and nostalgic crunch.
  • Lemon Sugar Bliss – Bright lemon zest and a delicate sugar finish.
  • Birthday Cake Confetti – Vanilla birthday cake flavor, colorful sprinkles and white chocolate.

Holiday & Seasonal

  • Gingerbread Spice – Molasses, ginger, cinnamon and warm spices.
  • Peppermint Chocolate Bark – Chocolate, white chocolate and peppermint.
  • Cranberry White Chocolate – Tart cranberries and creamy white chocolate.
  • Hot Cocoa Marshmallow – Rich chocolate with chocolate chips and marshmallow pieces.
  • Maple Brown Sugar Pecan – Warm maple, brown sugar and toasted pecans.

Gourmet Cookie Ordering Notice

To ensure every dozen is freshly handcrafted and prepared with care, please review our advance ordering requirements:

  • One Flavor (12 cookies): Order at least 48 hours in advance.
  • Two Flavors (6 cookies each): Order at least 72 hours in advance.
  • Three Flavors (4 cookies each): Order at least 96 hours (4 days) in advance.

Corporate & Bulk Orders: Please contact us directly to discuss order quantities, customization options, pricing, and required lead times.

All orders are subject to availability. Advance notice requirements apply to regular gourmet cookie orders.

Shop Now

Pickup, Delivery & Shipping

Pickup is available during our designated pickup windows. Local delivery within San Jacinto and Hemet is $5. Delivery to other areas and shipping are available for an additional fee. Our team will review your destination and contact you with the final shipping or delivery cost for approval before fulfillment.

Request Shipping / Out-of-Area Delivery

More Than Cookies. A Thoughtful Gifting Experience.

Beautifully Packaged. Personally Designed. Unforgettably Sweet.

Make every impression a sweet one. Our handcrafted gourmet cookies can be transformed into thoughtfully personalized gifts for clients, employees, colleagues and special occasions. From branded boxes and coordinating packaging to recipient names and personalized messages, we create a gifting experience that reflects your organization and makes every recipient feel appreciated.

  • Gift boxes with company logos, branded gift tags and recipient names.
  • Individually wrapped cookies, with a flavor identification label on every cookie.
  • Optional company logos or custom branding on individual cookie wrappers/labels.
  • Custom color-coordinated cookie labels, tissue paper, ribbons and bows.
  • Personalized flavor cards, including custom branded versions.
  • Personalized greeting cards, thank-you notes, holiday messages and recipient-specific notes.
  • Holiday, celebration and company-color themes; coordinated gift presentation.
  • Choice of available cookie flavors and cookies per box, subject to custom quote and production capabilities.
  • Bulk fulfillment, single-destination shipping, individual multi-recipient shipping, pickup and eligible local delivery.

Corporate Cookie Gifting — Custom Quotes Available. Pricing depends on box quantity, cookie count, flavors, branding, packaging, personalization, fulfillment and taxes.

Request a Corporate Gifting Quote

Big Cookies. Bigger Cravings.

Meet our Jumbo Gourmet Cookie Collection, available with Sunday Selections for Sunday pickup.

Shop Sunday Selections

Allergen Notice

Ingredients and allergens vary by flavor. Some cookies contain tree nuts, including macadamia nuts. If you have a food allergy, please contact us before ordering so we can confirm the ingredients and discuss possible cross-contact for the flavors you’re considering.